Pivot Tables vs VLOOKUP: When to Use Each in Excel

Franco Caoili, CPA, CMA
November 23, 2024
3 min read

This is Franco from WizDefy, and welcome to Excel Quick Tips! In this guide, we’ll explore the differences between Pivot Tables and VLOOKUP in Excel. You’ll learn when to use each tool—whether you’re extracting single values from different tables or summarizing large datasets. Let’s dive in!

Understanding the Data

We have two datasets:

  1. Sales for the Day: Includes Order ID, Sales Rep, Region, Product, and Quantity Sold.
  2. Inventory Listing: Contains items and their corresponding prices.

Our goal is to calculate Total Sales by filling out the Unit Price using these datasets.

When to Use VLOOKUP

VLOOKUP is ideal for:

  • Extracting single values.
  • Matching two tables together based on a common key.

How VLOOKUP Works

To fill out the Unit Price, we’ll use VLOOKUP. Here’s how:

  1. Use Product as the common key between the Sales and Inventory tables.
  2. Reference the table and indicate the column containing the Unit Price.
  3. Set the match type to exact for accurate results.
  4. Drag the formula down to populate the Unit Prices.
  5. Calculate Total Sales by multiplying Unit Price by Quantity and dragging the formula down.

VLOOKUP is perfect for this scenario, as it allows us to retrieve single values from a related table.

When to Use Pivot Tables

Pivot Tables are used to:

  • Summarize large datasets.
  • Analyze data with flexibility.

How to Create a Pivot Table

  1. Go to the Insert tab in the ribbon and click Pivot Table.
  2. Select your data range and choose where to place the Pivot Table (e.g., a new worksheet).
  3. Use the Pivot Table fields to summarize your data:
    • Drag Region to the Rows section.
    • Drag Total Sales to the Values section.

Examples of Pivot Table Use Cases

  1. Sales by Region: Quickly view total sales for East, North, South, and West regions.
  2. Sales by Product: Uncheck Region and select Product to see total sales for each item.
  3. Matrix View: Combine Region and Product in the Rows or Columns section to create a detailed breakdown.

Pivot Tables allow you to summarize and analyze data in seconds, offering unmatched flexibility.

Key Differences Between VLOOKUP and Pivot Tables

  • VLOOKUP: Used to find single values by linking two tables.
  • Pivot Tables: Used to summarize and organize large datasets.

Understanding the Tools

Think of it like this: a saw isn’t used to hammer nails, and a hammer won’t cut wood in half. Each tool has its specific purpose:

  • Use VLOOKUP to match tables and retrieve individual values.
  • Use Pivot Tables to aggregate and summarize data.

Conclusion

As a quick refresher:

  • Use VLOOKUP for finding single values.
  • Use Pivot Tables for summarizing large datasets.

I hope this guide has clarified the difference between these two essential Excel tools. This is Franco from Wisdify, and thank you for joining me on Excel Quick Tips. For more Excel insights, check out our other videos and resources!

About the Author

Franco Caoili, CPA, CMA

Franco Caoili, CPA, CMA

Continue Reading

Corey

Corey is the owner of Wisdify.  He is passionate about learning and development, he loves helping people achieve their professional and personal goals. Corey is a big believer in the power of online learning and community with 15 years of finance and accounting experience.

Joe

Joe is the owner of Wisdify.  He is passionate about learning and development, he loves helping people achieve their professional and personal goals. Joe is a big believer in the power of online learning and community with 20 years of finance and accounting experience.

 

Kelsey Murphy

Kelsey is Wisdify’s expert content developer. Taking feedback from our students, Kelsey creates extremely relevant blog posts and leads the development of Wisdify’s other free resources.

Prior to Wisdify, Kelsey worked as a business technology strategy consultant for Forrester, a global research and advisory firm. While there, she acted as project manager for numerous research-based consulting projects.

Kelsey earned a BA in Economics and Mathematics from Wellesley College.

Madison Bess

Madison oversees the social media strategy at Wisdify and makes sure we stay closely connected with our students, receive their feedback, and provide our students with valuable information.

Prior to Wisdify, Madison successfully ran the social media accounts for multiple companies. She also found time to start her own personal training company (which she still runs).

Madison earned a BA in English from Brigham Young University.

Maryn Coughran

Maryn is a co-founder and leads the marketing and outreach efforts at Wisdify. She ensures we are connecting with our customers, hearing their feedback, and then implementing their suggestions.

Prior to Wisdify, Maryn co-founded (along with Nate) BostonExcel, a Microsoft Excel training company that worked with dozens of companies in virtually every industry. Maryn’s clients included numerous Fortune 1000 companies, prestigious universities, startups and everything in between. She also happened to write and illustrate a children’s book. Let’s just say she’s a woman of many talents.

Maryn earned a BA in Economics from Wellesley College.

The Buckaroos

Gwyn, Jack, and Kate are the adorable tow-heads that lead up Wisdify’s campaigns on cuteness, energy, and sleep-deprivation.